Self-Defense or Second-Degree Murder?

Protest shooting may reveal hidden vulnerabilities within your ministry 

By Craig Cable, Director of Ministry Safety and Strategic Partnerships, American Church Group of Colorado 

On October 10, 2020, in Denver, Colorado, a 30-year-old private security guard who was hired to protect a Denver news crew while covering protests was involved in a deadly shooting that claimed the life of a 49-year-old man. 

According to multiple witnesses and substantiated by cell phone video captured at the scene, heated words were exchanged between the two parties, which resulted in a physical altercation where the security guard was slapped. Within a matter of seconds, the protester raised a can of pepper spray while nearly simultaneously, the security guard drew a concealed pistol and fired a single fatal shot. 

At first blush, this incident would appear to be far removed from any connection to your ministry. But from my perspective as a church security expert and security team trainer, I see several hidden vulnerabilities that could have significant implications for your ministry. 

Vunlerability #1:  Not All Ministry Security Team Members Understand the Reasonable Use of Force Standards 

When it comes to the use of deadly force in the state of Colorado, certain criteria must be met to justify the use of a deadly weapon against another person. According to Colorado Revised Statute 18-1-704 Use of Physical Force in Defense of a Person, the two main criteria for deadly force are: 

(1) Deadly force may also be used if in situations involving burglary or kidnapping. C.R.S § 18-1-704(2)(b)-(c).1  (2) the actor has reasonable ground to believe, and does believe, that he or another person is in imminent danger of being killed or of receiving great bodily injury. 

The Denver District Attorney and the legal system will now have to determine whether the escalation of circumstances rose to the threshold of justification for deadly force. Did the security guard reasonably believe that his life and the life of others were in imminent danger of being killed or receiving great bodily injury? For ministry leaders, you must ask the question, does every member of your church security team understand what is a reasonable response to any level of force—including deadly force? Their understanding or lack thereof will have a direct impact on your ministry. 

Vulnerability #2 Not All Ministry Security Team Members are Trained in the Use of Reasonable Force 

This incident demonstrates how quickly a situation can deteriorate. Initially, the security guard appears to be a bystander, but quickly finds himself in a situation involving the use of force. As a sworn officer and a private security professional, I can tell you that under high-stress situations, an individual will typically fall back on their highest level of training. If they have been trained in force options like de-escalation or open-handed defensive techniques, they are more likely to utilize those skills when needed. If they have received little to no training, their decisions will more likely be based on fear and survival instinct. 

A well-trained and practiced church security team will tend to make good decisions in a crisis. What decisions will your team make under extreme stress when the right answers are not glaringly clear? 

Vulnerability #3 Not all Ministries Purchase Insurance Coverage for Security Related Incidents 

Make no mistake, if a critical incident were to occur at your church, your ministry will never be the same. While we often think of protections in the physical sense, there should be protections in place that safeguard the health and well-being of your ministry, and the people who serve in it. We owe it to our congregations and our security team volunteers to care for their legal, physical, and emotional needs should you ever find yourself in a critical incident. For that reason, I implore the ministries that I work with to add two essential insurance coverages. 

The first is the Security Operations Liability Coverage. This endorsement covers your church or ministry leaders, your employees, and your emergency response personnel while they are acting on your behalf with the scope of their delegated authority. This coverage provides for medical coverage, wage loss, individual and family counseling, and even damage or loss of security-related equipment. 

The second essential endorsement is Traumatic Incident Response Coverage. This provides additional medical expenses, broadened wage loss reimbursement, and counseling to help heal the physical and emotional wounds of those who witnessed or were victims of the incident. It also provides reimbursement for temporary facility rental costs, for any expenses from additional security needs, and reimbursement costs for retaining legal counsel or a public relations specialist. 

While we pray that violence would never come to your ministries, no one can predict where or when violence is going to occur. It is important to remain vigilant and prepared for any situation. Whether it’s a domestic incident in your children’s ministry area or a mentally unstable person in your lobby, it’s essential that your volunteers are trained, practiced, and protected so that your ministry can survive the incident and continue to thrive afterward. 

To learn more about training opportunities that are available for your staff and church security team members, or the various coverages that Brotherhood Mutual Insurance Company® offers, I can be reached at CCable@AmericanChurchGroup.com


Craig is a sworn peace officer and serves as a Reserve Deputy Sheriff for the patrol division at the Larimer County Sheriff’s Office. In addition to protecting our streets, Craig also helps protect county schools as a school marshal. Craig has trained hundreds of security team leaders and volunteers and was the lead developer of the Safe and Secure Church: The Ministry Approach training kit produced in partnership with Group Publishing and Brotherhood Mutual Insurance Company. 
Source: FindLaw: For Legal Professionals. https://codes.findlaw.com/co/title-18-criminal-code/co-rev-st-sect-18-1-704.html 
Copyright. © 2020 American Church Group of Colorado, LLC. All rights reserved. The information is this article is intended to help your ministry better understand issues of vulnerability and mitigate risks. It does not constitute legal advice between an attorney and a client. If specific legal advice is required, your ministry is encouraged to consult with a local attorney. Neither Brotherhood Mutual Insurance Company, American Church of Colorado, LLC, nor Craig Cable assume liability for reliance upon the information provided in this article. 
July 22, 2021
Thousands in Relief Funding Available to Ministries Through the Employee Retention Credit
Thousands in Relief Funding Available to Ministries Through the Employee Retention Credit

Most ministry leaders don’t realize there is funding available to non-profit employers including churches, schools, colleges, and camps. This post includes some highlights about the credit and guidance on where to start to see if your ministry is eligible.

Tags: ERC, tax credit, payroll
April 23, 2021
Predictions and Insights for VBS 2021
Predictions and Insights for VBS 2021

If your church is anything like mine, Vacation Bible School (VBS) is a big deal. Not just because it is central to our ministry’s outreach to young families, but because of the important role that VBS plays in the spiritual formation of children.

Tags: COVID-19, health, health safety, protect, coronavirus, Christmas, risk management
April 13, 2021
Take Time to Review Your Ministry's Child Protection Plan
Take Time to Review Your Ministry's Child Protection Plan

April is National Child Abuse Prevention Month. Though child abuse may not be something you could ever imagine happening within your ministry, sexual abuse of a minor is one of the top five reasons churches end up in court, according to Church Law & Tax. Studies also show that a child is much more likely to be sexually abused by a trusted adult than a stranger.

Tags: safety, protect, child protection, youth, child abuse
March 16, 2021
Prepare for Severe Spring Storms Now
Prepare for Severe Spring Storms Now

When severe storms strike, they can produce high winds and tornadoes. Damaging winds can wreak havoc on your ministry’s property and to buildings. A high wind event can crash debris through your windows, strip your siding, down trees on your parking lot, peel shingles off your roof, and fling back the flashing.

Tags: weather emergency, lightning, storms, safety, protect
February 25, 2021
Catalytic Converter Theft on the Rise: Protect Ministry Vehicles
Catalytic Converter Theft on the Rise: Protect Ministry Vehicles

Thieves are taking advantage of soaring precious metal prices. Take steps to protect your ministry’s vehicles and property.

Tags: protect, theft, vehicles
February 15, 2021
Grant Funds Available for Safeguarding Ministries
Grant Funds Available for Safeguarding Ministries

As the Director of Ministry Safety for our agency, I am dedicated to finding ways to help safeguard ministries like yours.

Tags: COVID-19, health, health safety, protect, coronavirus, Christmas, risk management
February 5, 2021
Avoid Frozen Pipes as Temperatures Plummet
Avoid Frozen Pipes as Temperatures Plummet

As temperatures plummet, the risk of freezing pipes jumps. Frozen pipes can cause costly messes that could also put your ministry on hold while you clean up.

Tags: frozen, building, pipes, prevent damage
January 12, 2021
Potential Vulnerabilities in School's Safety Plan
Are there hidden vulnerabilities in your school's safety plan?

On behalf of our agency, I recently participated in one such training which focused on strategies and tactics for responding as a single officer to an active safety threat in a school building.

Tags: COVID-19, health, health safety, protect, coronavirus, Christmas, risk management
January 5, 2021
Church Safety Trends for 2021
Church Safety Trends for 2021

If you’re anything like me (and maybe the rest of the world for that matter), you’re grateful to put the craziness of the past year behind us.

Tags: COVID-19, health, health safety, protect, coronavirus, Christmas, risk management
November 23, 2020
COVID-19 and the Christmas Season
COVID-19 and the Christmas Season

Preparing for this Christmas season may require additional creativity, due to the uncertainty of what COVID-19 may bring in our local community.

Tags: COVID-19, health, health safety, protect, coronavirus, Christmas, risk management
October 28, 2020
Guidance for Ministries About Boy Scouts' Bankruptcy
Guidance for Ministries About Boy Scouts' Bankruptcy

A mid-November deadline in the Boy Scouts of America’s (BSA) bankruptcy proceedings may have you wondering what the organization’s bankruptcy filing means for your ministry if you ever hosted or chartered Boy Scout Troops.

Tags: coverage, protect, liability, damages, youth
October 27, 2020
Self-Defense or Second-Degree Murder?
Self-Defense or Second-Degree Murder?

On October 10, 2020, in Denver, Colorado, a 30-year-old private security guard who was hired to protect a Denver news crew while covering protests was involved in a deadly shooting that claimed the life of a 49-year-old man. 

October 1, 2020
Applying for PPP Loan Forgiveness
Applying for PPP Loan Forgiveness

Organizations that obtained Paycheck Protection Program (PPP) funding through the CARES Act can have their loans forgiven, turning them into grants. To qualify, each borrower must file a forgiveness application with its PPP lender, proving that it followed the rules. If your church, school, college, or camp meets all the criteria, 100% of its loan can be forgiven.

August 27, 2020
Emergency Dispatch: Cameron Peak
Emergency Dispatch: Cameron Peak

Lessons learned from the front line of a wildland fire.

Tags: liability, damages, protect, directors and officers, coverage
August 20, 2020
Colorado Wildfires: Prepare Your Ministry Now
Colorado Wildfires: Prepare Your Ministry Now

Four major wildfires are burning across Colorado, fueled by dry vegetation, drought and wind.

Tags: liability, damages, protect, directors and officers, coverage
April 13, 2020
Beware of COVID-19 Cyber Scams
Beware of COVID-19 Cyber Scams

Ministries are creatively scrambling to continue their operations and safely engage their congregations with an array of online technologies during the coronavirus pandemic. Unfortunately, hackers are ready to take advantage of the confusion with scams designed to steal valuable data or siphon funds from your ministry. Learn how to keep your ministry safe from scams. 

Tags: liability, damages, protect, directors and officers, coverage
March 30, 2020
CARES Act: Churches Need to Apply Now
UPDATED: CARES Act: Churches Need to Apply Now

Learn about the CARES Act and two loans for which ministries may be eligible, since Congress authorized additional funding April 23. 

March 6, 2020
Coronavirus and Your Ministry: Tips for Prevention
Coronavirus and Your Ministry: Tips for Prevention

As concern over the dangers associated with the spread of a new coronavirus, COVID-19, spreads, our agency and Brotherhood Mutual want to keep you informed and provide best practices for managing the spread of this and similar illnesses at your ministry.

January 29, 2020
Hosting a Game Day Bash? Brush Up on Copyright Basics
Hosting a Game Day Bash? Brush Up on Copyright Basics

The first Sunday in February is a big day for sports fans. In fact, many Americans view Super Bowl Sunday as a national holiday. Friends and families will gather this year to watch the big game, enjoy delicious snacks, and of course, critique the commercials that go along with game day.

October 28, 2019
Are You Covered If You're Injured Overseas?
Are You Covered If You're Injured Overseas?

Recently, we learned about two major overseas incidents involving pastors on mission trips. The first incident involved a pastor being hit by a motorcycle while running. The second was a bus accident involving two pastors. The runner and one of the two bus passengers sustained extensive injuries.

Tags: missions, insurance