Tragedy in Nashville: What can we learn from the Covenant School shooting?

Written by Craig Cable, Director of Ministry Safety, ACG Colorado

 

Once again, we find ourselves in a state of shock, grief, anger, and loss after another school shooting, this time in a K-6 Christian school in Nashville, TN. While details are still emerging about the incident, I want to take the opportunity to respond to questions or concerns that may be swirling around your church or school.

As a father, husband, and son, my heart breaks for the families who lost their children and loved ones. However, as a security team leader, professional tactics trainer, and member of law enforcement, I don't have the luxury of simply processing my emotions and grieving the loss. Rather, I am compelled to compartmentalize the incident into timelines, tactics, and lessons learned. If anything positive can come out of this tragedy, it's that we can use the experience to learn and prepare to help prevent the next tragedy from occurring.

The following is a breakdown of the events that occurred at Covenant Christian School on March 27, 2023. I have included some of my thoughts and questions for you to consider as we strive to learn from this senseless act of violence.

The Arrival and Entering the School

The shooter pulled into the parking lot of the school at 9:53 am. Approximately 17 minutes later, at 10:10 am, they entered the main entrance of the school by breaching the glass doors with several shots fired from one of two rifles they were carrying. I believe that the need to breach the doors most likely saved lives. Shots being fired probably alerted faculty to the attack, which may have also resulted in the deployment of the alarm system. Had the doors been unlocked, the shooter would have most likely walked into the building unchallenged, catching more teachers and students by surprise and unprepared.

Thoughts to consider:

  • It's very difficult to keep your eyes on every parking lot all of the time. However, monitored camera systems watching for individuals approaching the exterior entrances with weapons may have bought precious time to sound the alarm. How are your parking lot or entrances being monitored?
  • Breaching the glass doors of a school with a firearm is not a new tactic. That's exactly what happened in the Sandy Hook Elementary School shooting in 2012, which resulted in the deaths of twenty children and six adults. For many schools and churches, bullet-resistant film on glass is cost-prohibitive. If your facility does not have that safeguard, it's important to recognize that glass doors may serve to slow down an attacker, but they most likely won't stop someone who is motivated to get in. Are there ways you can help shore up your entrances to help delay or discourage access into the building?
  • Preparedness is everything when an incident like this occurs. It's imperative that everyone knows and has practiced the emergency response plan so that time is not wasted developing an ill-conceived plan on the fly. How prepared and practiced are your staff and volunteers?

The Attack

The first 911 call came to the Metro Nashville Police Department dispatch center at 10:13 am. Once inside the building, surveillance footage from interior cameras observed the shooter moving purposefully in and around the hallways and the office area of the school. The body language of this individual indicated that they had a single focus in mind, which was to find individuals to kill. Based on the video, it appeared that most students and faculty were either safely barricaded in their rooms or potentially evacuating out another door.

Thoughts to consider:

  • Statistically speaking, most active killer events happen very quickly and last only a few minutes. What often determines the duration of the attack is the attacker's ability to locate potential victims or be stopped by someone who intervenes in the attack. How quickly can someone engage a threat at your location should an attack occur?
  • Limiting an attacker's movement within the building can help buy time and save lives. This can be accomplished by requiring key codes or fobs to access locked hallways or closed-off sections of the building. What can you do in your building to prevent an attacker from having free reign to roam the halls?
  • While this detail may not have come to light yet, it appeared that this school did not have individuals dedicated to the role of security. Assigning administrators, custodians, or teachers to be security members on top of their assigned duties creates a challenge when timing, training, and the ability to respond in a meaningful way truly matter. Who could you recruit or hire to provide a dedicated focus on safety and security?

Law Enforcement Response

If you have watched the body camera footage of the two officers who responded to the attack at the school, you are seeing textbook active shooter response tactics in action. You will see the officers quickly assemble a two or three-man entry team. Their communications are concise and deliberate as they work together as a team. Their movements in clearing the initial rooms of threats are efficient and methodical. Once the gunfire was heard, their response to the second floor was expedient and coordinated. The tactics they used to position an officer with a specific weapon in the lead to stop the threat were all consistent with the training that patrol officers received. I have received much of the same training that these patrol officers had, and their tactics were spot on. Without a doubt, their training and speed of action saved lives.

Thoughts to consider:

  • You will notice that a representative from the school met the responding officers outside and provided them with critical information about what was occurring and where the shooter may be. You will also notice that she communicated to the officers that two children were missing. If this incident had occurred at your location, who would most likely be the one to communicate with the first responders, and would they have the ability to know the status of everyone's whereabouts in the building?
  • The officers' body camera footage provides a unique glimpse into the chaos and stress of an active shooter incident. The officers' ability to control their emotions and adrenaline to focus on the critical task at hand is both extraordinary and commendable. How will your staff and volunteers handle the chaos and stress while trying to keep people safe until help arrives?
  • In my opinion, this attack could have been much worse if it had not been for the quick actions of the faculty and first officers on the scene. The fact that the shooter had positioned themselves in an elevated position in the building and was shooting out a window at police was a positive outcome because it meant that she wasn't in classrooms killing children. How can you use this tragic incident to have a conversation with your staff and volunteers about the importance of training and preparation?

Reunifying Families

As details continue to emerge, we are hearing stories of teachers who sheltered their children in closets and even evacuated them into the surrounding woods to ensure their safety. Imagine the terror, dread, and confusion felt by the parents as they begin to arrive at the school, not knowing if their child is safe or not. Reunifying children with their parents is the next important step once the crisis is over. This is a process that needs to be managed carefully and compassionately.

Here are some thoughts to consider:

  • In this situation, children were relocated to a safe location predetermined in their emergency response plans. The school administrators' preplanning allowed them the opportunity to focus on the needs of the families rather than expending time and energy trying to get a game plan together. If there was a critical incident at your location, where would individuals evacuate to, and how would loved ones know to find them there?
  • The reunification process is highly dependent on knowing exactly where everyone is. Going back to the school representative who alerted the officers of the two missing children, this level of accountability would have been very difficult had the children been in the hallways, common areas, or on the playground at the time of the attack. Having an accurate room roster and the ability to know when everyone is accounted for or missing will help expedite the process of reunification. This situation can be dramatically improved with the use of radios or an online application so that room leaders can quickly communicate with staff. How would you manage the evacuation, communication, and reunification process?
  • Be prepared for the reality that families looking for loved ones won't find them at the reunification point. They may be in the hospital, or they may have lost their lives in the attack. Have a plan for how the information will be delicately communicated to families impacted. Do you have grief counselors in your ministry that could assist with the notification process?

I think it is clear to us all that had it not been for the heroics of the teachers and staff and the expedient response of law enforcement, this attack could have been far worse. This school had invested time and effort into developing its emergency response plan and had received training to help ensure that everyone could execute the plan when needed. Their preparation and actions bought them precious minutes that allowed law enforcement to respond and end the threat.

Brotherhood Mutual understands the need for ministries to be prepared and has created an entire online safety library filled with best practices, checklists, and training videos. They also have specialized coverages that we put on every policy to help a ministry heal and rebuild after a tragedy.

Our prayers are with the families impacted by this senseless act, and our hearts are with all of the Christian schools that we serve who may be feeling anxious or ill-prepared. As your risk management partner, please know that we're not only here to help you navigate the process of safeguarding your ministry, but we stand alongside you in the important role you play in helping our children come to know and love Jesus in a world that desperately needs him.

 

Craig is a sworn peace officer and serves as a Reserve Deputy Sheriff for the patrol division at the Larimer County Sheriff's Office. has trained hundreds of security team leaders and volunteers and was the lead developer of the Safe and Secure & Church: The Ministry Approach training kit produced in partnership with Group Publishing and Brotherhood Mutual Insurance Company.  

 

If you have further questions about protecting your ministry, please feel free to reach out to me at ccable@americanchurchgroup.com.    

 

Copyright. © 2023 American Church Group of Colorado, LLC. All rights reserved. The information in this article is intended to help your ministry better understand issues of vulnerability and mitigate risks.? It does not constitute legal advice between an attorney and a client. If specific legal advice is required, your ministry is encouraged to consult with a local attorney. Neither Brotherhood Mutual Insurance Company, American Church of Colorado, LLC, nor the author assumes liability for reliance upon the information provided in this article. 

 

November 7, 2023
Three common pitfalls that may be hidden in your church's lease
Three Common Pitfalls That May Be Hidden In Your Church's Lease

One positive aspect of today’s challenged economy is the availability of underutilized or empty commercial space. Before your ministry takes the plunge into a lease agreement, we want to make sure you're well-informed and prepared to avoid some common pitfalls.

Tags: ministry, lease, property
November 7, 2023
Insurance Companies Are Forced To Respond To Unprecedented Market Strain. What Does This Mean For You?
Insurance Companies Are Forced To Respond To Unprecedented Market Strain. What Does This Mean For You?

In this month's perspective on the insurance market, I wanted to talk about the massive upward trending we are seeing in cancellation of policies.  Our agency has observed a remarkable surge in inquiries from churches not currently under our insurance coverage. These churches are facing non-renewal by their existing carriers, a trend that has expanded beyond the norm of non-renewals due to excessive losses. Instead, carriers are now opting not to renew based on the risk profile of the ministry, which encompasses factors like geography, insured value, and construction type.

Tags: market strain, weather, catastrophic losses, renewal, risk
November 7, 2023
Umbrella for a Rainy Day
Umbrella for a Rainy Day

There are so many insurance policies to consider when it comes to protecting your ministry, and keeping track of each one’s coverages can be a mind-numbing task. One that I often hear confusion about is the Excess Liability policy, more commonly referred to as an Umbrella. While these terms aren’t exactly interchangeable in the broader insurance world, they do have a lot of overlap. For purposes of understanding your Brotherhood Mutual policy, they are basically synonymous.

Tags: ministry protection, coverages, liability, umbrella policy
October 6, 2023
The Crucial Role of Key Man Life Insurance for Church Pastors
The Crucial Role of Key Man Life Insurance for Church Pastors

In recent times, our team has observed a growing demand for key man life insurance, particularly within the realm of church leadership. Pastors are the spiritual pillars of their congregations, providing guidance, support, and a sense of community. While their spiritual contributions are invaluable, it's equally important to consider their financial well-being and the stability of the church should an unforeseen tragedy occur.

Tags: finance, security, church pastor, community
October 6, 2023
Wellbeing Resources for Ministry Leaders
Wellbeing Resources for Ministry Leaders

The holiday season is fast approaching, and it's time to prepare for the festive cheer, delicious food, twinkling lights, and heartwarming gatherings. But amidst all the joy and celebration, let's take a moment to reflect on something essential - the well-being of our ministry leaders.

Tags: full strength network, counseling, church pastor, pastoral counseling
October 6, 2023
Stop Plumbing Leaks with FloLogic
Stop Plumbing Leaks with FloLogic

Water damage due to plumbing leaks and frozen pipes is a leading cause of property claims for ministries. The damage is often made worse because ministry buildings are typically not in use every day. Last year, nearly 1,000 Brotherhood Mutual Insurance Company customers were impacted. To help protect ministries from experiencing costly water damage and disruptions, Brotherhood Mutual® recommends FloLogic, a comprehensive solution that can detect even the smallest water leak and automatically shut off the water to prevent flooding. 

Tags: flologic, leaks, water damage, prevention
September 8, 2023
Fluorescent Lighting: The End of An Era
Fluorescent Lighting: The End of An Era

Let's take a stroll down memory lane to 1938 when General Electric made a groundbreaking move by introducing fluorescent tubes to the world. Even though the technology had been brewing since the late 1880s, it took time and the genius of several inventors to make it shine as a practical product.

Tags: church payroll, finance, IRS regulations, paying employees, tax code
September 8, 2023
God's Sovereignty or Wise Planning?
God's Sovereignty or Wise Planning?

We are living in a day and age of tremendous uncertainty. Like Joseph in Egypt, the physical world is incredibly unpredictable.

Tags: church payroll, finance, IRS regulations, paying employees, tax code
September 8, 2023
Why Some Churches are Rethinking their Financial Planning
Why Some Churches are Rethinking their Financial Planning

In the ever-changing realm of finances, the past few years have brought forth a whirlwind of alterations. Looking ahead, the next five years promise their fair share of surprises and uncertainties.

Tags: church payroll, finance, IRS regulations, paying employees, tax code
September 8, 2023
HR360: Your Essential Guide to Navigating Ministry-Specific HR Challenges
HR360: Your Essential Guide to Navigating Ministry-Specific HR Challenges

In the dynamic landscape of today's world, managing the HR needs of any ministry can be a complex and ever-changing endeavor. Whether you're dealing with sensitive situations that demand careful handling to avoid legal entanglements or aiming to proactively establish risk management strategies, the journey can be demanding.

Tags: church payroll, finance, IRS regulations, paying employees, tax code
August 8, 2023
Understand your Medical Coverage for Students & Volunteers
Understand your Medical Coverage for Students & Volunteers

As we gear up for the upcoming school season, it's a fantastic opportunity to take a closer look at the coverage we offer to our beloved students and dedicated volunteers.

Tags: medical coverage, students, voluteers
August 8, 2023
Auto Insurance Trends: What Does that Mean for your Ministry?
Auto Insurance Trends: What Does that Mean for your Ministry?

Are you tired of constantly hearing about rising expenses? It seems like every time I turn around, whether it's at the grocery store, the gas station, or even dealing with insurance, I'm faced with the reality of higher costs.

Tags: auto insurance, auto, coverage, ministry
August 8, 2023
Rethinking Insurance: Offering a Fresh Perspective
Rethinking Insurance: Offering a Fresh Perspective

Let's face it, the world is constantly changing, and it's fascinating to witness the rapid evolution happening around us. Some futurists even predict that in the next two decades, the rate of change could be four times what it is today, and an astounding 16 times in 40 years.

Tags: Rethinking insurance, insurance, PC, property, risk mitigation
July 7, 2023
Upcoming Security Trainings
Tags: insurance, coverage, ministry
July 7, 2023
Pepper Spray Usage
Considering pepper spray for your security team? Here are some things you need to know.
Tags: insurance, coverage, ministry
July 7, 2023
Protecting Your Assets
Protecting Your Assets: Broadened Valuation for Peace of Mind
Tags: insurance, coverage, ministry
April 3, 2023
Tragedy in Nashville
Tragedy in Nashville: What can we learn from the Covenant School shooting?
Tags: insurance, coverage, ministry
March 17, 2023
Worry-Free Mission Travel
Worry-Free Mission Travel
Tags: insurance, coverage, ministry
March 17, 2023
HR Document Library at your Fingertips
HR Document Library at your Fingertips
Tags: insurance, coverage, ministry
March 17, 2023
Highlights from Recent Security Training Events
Tags: insurance, coverage, ministry